Every fall, millions of seniors face the same decision: Medigap vs Medicare Advantage — which is right for me? Despite Medicare Advantage’s heavy marketing, a significant number of seniors deliberately choose Medigap over Medicare Advantage. Here’s why.
The Core Reason Seniors Choose Medigap Over Medicare Advantage
The fundamental difference: Medicare Advantage is cheaper at enrollment but can cost far more when you’re sick. Medigap vs Medicare Advantage comes down to predictability. With Medigap Plan G, after the Part B deductible ($257 in 2026), you pay nothing for covered services all year. With Medicare Advantage, copays, coinsurance, and prior authorizations can add up to thousands.
Nurses, doctors, and hospital administrators — people who see how insurance affects patients — consistently prefer Medigap for themselves and their families. The reason: when a serious illness hits, Medicare Advantage plans frequently require prior authorization, restrict networks, and deny claims that Original Medicare would cover.
According to Medicare.gov, Medigap plans work alongside Original Medicare and cover most of the gaps Original Medicare leaves — without network restrictions or prior authorization requirements.
Five Reasons Seniors Choose Medigap Over Medicare Advantage
Any doctor, anywhere: Medigap works with any provider who accepts Medicare — no networks, no referrals
No prior authorization: Your doctor decides your care — not an insurance company algorithm
Mayo Clinic access: Mayo Clinic Arizona accepts Original Medicare and Medigap — not most Advantage plans
Predictable costs: One deductible per year, then nothing for covered services
Stable benefits: Medigap benefits don’t change annually — no ANOC to review every September
When Medicare Advantage Might Still Make Sense
If you can’t afford Medigap premiums or qualify for low-income assistance programs, Medicare Advantage may be your best available option. However, the one-way door risk remains: if you later want to choose Medigap over Medicare Advantage, you may need to pass medical underwriting.
Get a Free Comparison in Arizona
I’m Andy Orlikoff, an independent Medicare broker in Surprise, AZ. I help Arizona seniors understand the real Medigap vs Medicare Advantage tradeoffs — and I don’t sell Advantage plans.
If you’re tempted to ditch Medicare Advantage, you’re not alone. Millions of Americans switch away from Medicare Advantage plans every year — and the numbers are growing. Here’s when it makes sense to leave, how to do it, and the critical timing issue most people miss.
Why More People Are Choosing to Ditch Medicare Advantage
The most common reasons people decide to ditch Medicare Advantage:
Their doctor left the plan’s network
Prior authorization denied necessary care
Out-of-pocket costs were higher than expected after a serious illness
Benefits were cut at the annual renewal
Moving to a different part of Arizona or another state
Wanting access to Mayo Clinic, which doesn’t accept most Advantage plans
According to CMS data, Medicare Advantage enrollment has seen increasing churn as plan benefits change annually and major insurers pull back from markets.
The Critical Warning Before You Ditch Medicare Advantage
Here’s what stops many people from leaving: the one-way door problem. If you ditch Medicare Advantage and want to switch to a Medicare Supplement (Medigap) plan, you may need to pass medical underwriting — especially if you’ve been on Advantage for more than a year.
That means insurance companies can review your health history and potentially deny you Medigap coverage or charge more based on pre-existing conditions. The longer you stay on Medicare Advantage, the more health conditions you may accumulate — and the harder it becomes to qualify for Medigap.
This is why timing matters: if you’re thinking about leaving, do it sooner rather than later.
When You Can Ditch Medicare Advantage Without Penalty
There are two main windows to leave Medicare Advantage:
Medicare Advantage Open Enrollment Period (MA OEP): January 1 – March 31. You can switch to Original Medicare, with coverage starting the first of the following month.
Annual Enrollment Period (AEP): October 15 – December 7. Changes take effect January 1.
What to Do After You Ditch Medicare Advantage
Once you return to Original Medicare, you’ll want a Medicare Supplement Plan G to cover your out-of-pocket costs. With Plan G, after the Part B deductible ($257 in 2026), you pay nothing for covered services for the rest of the year — no networks, no prior authorization, no surprises.
Ready to Make the Switch?
I’m Andy Orlikoff, an independent Medicare broker in Surprise, AZ. I help Arizona seniors who want to ditch Medicare Advantage navigate the process and enroll in the right Medigap plan — even when medical underwriting is required.
As you approach the age of 65, understanding the various Medicare options available to you can feel overwhelming. Two of the most popular choices—Medicare Supplement Part G and Medicare Advantage plans—often cause confusion among beneficiaries. While both plans aim to fill gaps in Original Medicare, they are vastly different in terms of coverage, cost, and flexibility. This comprehensive guide will help you understand Medigap Part G and Medicare Advantage options, making it easier to choose the right plan based on your healthcare needs.
Understanding Medicare Supplement Part G
What is Medicare Supplement Part G?
Medicare Supplement Part G, often referred to as Medigap Part G, is a private insurance plan that works alongside Original Medicare (Parts A and B) to cover “gaps” in Medicare. These gaps include out-of-pocket expenses such as copayments, coinsurance, and deductibles that Medicare doesn’t cover. Essentially, Part G helps reduce the financial burden of medical costs by supplementing Original Medicare’s limitations.
What Does Part G Cover?
Medicare Supplement Part G offers comprehensive coverage, second only to the now-unavailable Medicare Supplement Plan F. It covers:
Medicare Part A coinsurance and hospital costs (up to an additional 365 days after Medicare benefits are exhausted)
Medicare Part B coinsurance or copayments
Part A deductible
Skilled nursing facility care coinsurance
Part B excess charges (the difference between what a provider charges and what Medicare will pay)
Foreign travel emergency coverage (up to plan limits)
The only thing Part G doesn’t cover is the Medicare Part B deductible, which as of 2024 is $226 annually. Otherwise, it covers nearly all out-of-pocket costs for Medicare-approved services.
Pros of Medicare Supplement Part G
Comprehensive Coverage: You pay very little out of pocket beyond your monthly premiums, providing peace of mind when facing high medical expenses.
No Network Restrictions: Medigap Part G allows you to see any doctor or specialist nationwide who accepts Medicare, offering greater flexibility.
Predictable Costs: With Part G, you can anticipate your healthcare costs, knowing that you’ll be covered for most of the expenses not included in Original Medicare.
Cons of Medicare Supplement Part G
Higher Premiums: Medigap Part G tends to have higher monthly premiums compared to other Medigap plans and Medicare Advantage options.
Does Not Include Drug Coverage: Part G does not cover prescription drugs, so you’ll need to purchase a Medicare Part D plan separately for drug coverage.
No Extra Perks: Unlike some Medicare Advantage plans, Medigap Part G doesn’t offer additional benefits like vision, dental, or hearing care.
What is Medicare Advantage?
How Does Medicare Advantage Work?
Medicare Advantage plans (also known as Medicare Part C) are an all-in-one alternative to Original Medicare, offered by private insurers. These plans must provide at least the same level of coverage as Original Medicare but often include additional benefits like prescription drug coverage, vision, dental, and hearing care. Medicare Advantage plans bundle Medicare Part A, Part B, and sometimes Part D into a single plan, offering beneficiaries convenience and potentially lower overall costs.
Types of Medicare Advantage Plans
There are several types of Medicare Advantage plans, including:
Health Maintenance Organization (HMO): Requires you to use a network of doctors and hospitals, and you need a referral to see a specialist.
Preferred Provider Organization (PPO): Offers more flexibility by allowing you to see doctors outside of the network at a higher cost, and no referrals are needed for specialists.
Private Fee-for-Service (PFFS): Allows you to see any provider that accepts the plan’s payment terms, but provider acceptance is not guaranteed.
Special Needs Plans (SNPs): Tailored for people with specific diseases or conditions, these plans offer specialized care management.
Pros of Medicare Advantage Plans
Lower Monthly Premiums: Many Medicare Advantage plans have low or even $0 monthly premiums, making them an attractive option for cost-conscious beneficiaries.
All-in-One Coverage: These plans often include prescription drug coverage (Part D) and additional benefits like vision, dental, and hearing care.
Additional Benefits: Medicare Advantage plans may offer extras such as gym memberships, wellness programs, and telehealth services.
Cons of Medicare Advantage Plans
Network Restrictions: Most Medicare Advantage plans have network limitations, requiring you to use specific doctors and hospitals. You may need referrals to see specialists.
Variable Costs: While premiums may be low, out-of-pocket costs can vary greatly, especially if you need care outside of your plan’s network.
Limited Nationwide Coverage: Unlike Medigap Part G, Medicare Advantage plans may not provide the same level of nationwide coverage, making them less suitable for frequent travelers.
Medicare Supplement Part G vs. Medicare Advantage: A Direct Comparison
Now that we’ve reviewed the basics of both Medigap Part G and Medicare Advantage, let’s dive into a side-by-side comparison to highlight their key differences.
1. Coverage Options
Medigap Part G: Covers nearly all out-of-pocket costs that Original Medicare does not, including Part A deductible, Part B coinsurance, and excess charges. However, it does not include prescription drugs or additional perks like dental and vision care.
Medicare Advantage: Offers all-in-one coverage, often bundling Medicare Parts A, B, and D with extra benefits like vision, dental, and hearing care. However, it comes with network restrictions and varying out-of-pocket costs.
2. Cost
Medigap Part G: Higher monthly premiums but predictable and stable out-of-pocket costs for covered services. You’ll need to buy a separate Part D plan for drug coverage.
Medicare Advantage: Generally lower or no monthly premiums, but more unpredictable out-of-pocket expenses, especially if you go outside the plan’s network. Prescription drug coverage is often included.
3. Flexibility
Medigap Part G: Allows you to see any doctor who accepts Medicare, without worrying about network restrictions. This makes it ideal for those who travel frequently or want the freedom to choose any provider.
Medicare Advantage: Often requires you to stay within a specific network of healthcare providers. While some plans, like PPOs, offer more flexibility, you’ll still pay more to see out-of-network doctors.
4. Prescription Drug Coverage
Medigap Part G: Does not include prescription drug coverage. You’ll need to enroll in a separate Medicare Part D plan.
Medicare Advantage: Most plans include prescription drug coverage, offering convenience and potentially saving you the cost of purchasing a separate plan.
5. Additional Benefits
Medigap Part G: Focuses on supplementing Original Medicare, so it doesn’t offer additional benefits like dental, vision, or hearing care.
Medicare Advantage: Often includes these extras, making it a more comprehensive option for those looking for additional non-medical services.
Which Plan is Right for You?
When choosing between Medicare Supplement Part G and Medicare Advantage plans, your decision will largely depend on your personal healthcare needs and lifestyle.
Choose Medigap Part G if:
You want comprehensive coverage for out-of-pocket Medicare expenses and don’t want to deal with network restrictions.
You value predictability in your healthcare costs and don’t mind paying higher monthly premiums for peace of mind.
You travel frequently and need access to doctors and hospitals nationwide.
Choose Medicare Advantage if:
You are looking for an affordable option with lower monthly premiums, especially if you’re on a fixed income.
You prefer an all-in-one plan that includes drug coverage and extra benefits like dental, vision, and hearing care.
You don’t mind using a network of healthcare providers and are comfortable with some unpredictability in out-of-pocket expenses.
Conclusion
Choosing between Medicare Supplement Part G and Medicare Advantage plans is a critical decision that can impact your healthcare and financial well-being. Each plan offers unique benefits, with Medigap Part G providing comprehensive coverage and flexibility, while Medicare Advantage plans are more affordable and offer additional benefits. Understanding the key differences and considering your personal healthcare needs will ensure that you select the right Medicare coverage option that works best for you.
Need Affordable Health Plans in Surprise, AZ?
At American Insurance Benefits, we’re passionate about helping individuals and families in Arizona secure the health insurance coverage they need at a price they can afford. Since 2004, Andy Orlikoff and our team have been dedicated to making the process of finding the right plan as simple and stress-free as possible. If you’re looking for expert guidance tailored to your unique needs and budget, don’t hesitate to reach out to us today. Let’s find the perfect health insurance solution together.
When you turn 65, the biggest Medicare decision you’ll face is this: Original Medicare vs Medicare Advantage — which one is right for you? The differences are significant, and one expert says one of those options is clearly the worse choice for most seniors. Here’s the full breakdown.
As you approach age 65, you’ll have some decisions to make about medical coverage. On one hand, you can enroll in Medicare. But you may be tempted to choose another option instead: a Medicare Advantage (MA) plan instead. If you’ve seen the advertisements for MA plans, you might think they’re more cost-effective and comprehensive than Medicare. But according to Keith Armbrecht, Founder of Medicare education company, Medicare on Video, that’s not necessarily true.
“I would never choose a Medicare advantage plan,” he says in a YouTube video entitled “Why Medicare Advantage Is The Worst Choice For Seniors.”
Here’s why he’s not a fan of these plans.
What is a Medicare Advantage plan?
Medicare Advantage plans are alternative insurance plans to Medicare, and they’re offered by Medicare-approved private companies. These plans are sometimes called “Part C” or “MA,” and they include Medicare Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance).
Those interested in MA have more than 40 different plans to choose from. The main
reasons to explore them include:
The potential for lower premiums compared to Medicare. In 2022, the average premium was $58, according to 2022 data from the U.S. Senate Committee on Finance.
Out-of-pocket costs may be capped. In 2023, the maximum was $8,300 for approved services.
Most plans include dental, vision, hearing and fitness benefits.
That being said, there are a few downsides to Medicare Advantage plans. Here are some important things to consider before locking into an MA plan.
Limited choice
If you opt for an MA plan, your choice of doctors can be limited and you’re likely to face obstacles in getting approved for procedures or seeing specialists. “The primary reason I would absolutely choose original Medicare and would never choose Medicare Advantage is because I want control over what I do,” says Armbrecht. With an MA plan, he warns, you can face wait times of “weeks, even months,” to get referrals or have procedures authorized.
You’re typically limited to doctors in the plan network and service area, as well,
according to the government’s Medicare website.
Deceptive marketing
The Medicare Advantage plan industry has a history of deceptive practices. In 2022, the Majority Staff of the U.S. Senate Committee on Finance found that Medicare beneficiaries were being inundated with aggressive marketing tactics, false and misleading information and overall predatory marketing from MA providers. According to the report, deceptive Medicare Advantage marketing practices are, “widespread, not isolated events.”
According to a 2022 review from the New York Times, four out of five of the largest MA providers (UnitedHealth, Humana, Elevance and Kaiser) have faced federal lawsuits for fraud and at least eight providers overbilled, according to the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services Office of the Inspector General.
Denied claims
Multiple studies have shown MA plans have a pattern of denying claims that should be covered.
A 2022 review from the Inspector General’s office found that MAs denied 13% of prior authorization requests that met Medicare coverage rules. Essentially, these claims would have been approved under original Medicare. The most commonly denied requests were imaging services, stays in post-acute facilities and injections.
Go to the source
“Medicare is probably the only government program that does exactly what it’s supposed to do and does it very well,” says Armbrecht. In other words, original Medicare is likely your best choice. If you’re nearing 65 and considering your options, you can visit Medicare.Gov for accurate and up-to-date information so you can make the right decision for your health insurance needs.
For most Arizona seniors, Original Medicare with Plan G provides better protection when you need care most. Call Andy Orlikoff at (623) 742-3878 for a free, no-pressure comparison.
Many enrollees don’t realize how many little-known Medicare benefits are available to them. Beyond hospital and doctor coverage, Original Medicare pays for a surprising range of preventive and specialized services. Here are 10 little-known Medicare benefits you may be missing.
Medicare’s basic, original Part A (hospital insurance) and Part B (medical insurance) cover obvious things you expect from health insurance: hospital stays, appointments with your doctor when you’re sick, ambulance services, flu shots. But the government’s healthcare program for Americans 65 or older also pays for many things that might surprise you.
If you’re on Medicare or are approaching that time of your life, you’ll want to be aware of these 10 Medicare benefits that enrollees often don’t know about and that can keep you from dipping into your savings.
1. Annual ‘Wellness Visits’
Once you’ve had Medicare Part B coverage for a year, you’ll get what’s called an annual wellness visit with your doctor, who will take routine measurements, such as your height, weight, and blood pressure, and review your medical history. You’ll fill out a “Health Risk Assessment” questionnaire to identify risk factors — so you and your doctor can work on keeping you healthy. Medicare says the appointments also can include “detection of any cognitive impairment.” That means your physician will be on alert for signs of Alzheimer’s or similar ailments.
2. Obesity Counseling
Obesity causes many illnesses and can make frail older bodies much weaker. Diabetes and heart disease rates skyrocket for those who are overweight or obese. Joint and bone diseases are easier to manage at healthy weight levels. If you have a Body Mass Index (BMI) reading of 30 or more, Medicare will cover face-to-face counseling sessions in a primary care setting (like a doctor’s office) to help you bring your weight down to a healthier level.
3. Help to Quit Smoking
If you’re a smoker, Medicare can help you kick the habit. Letting go can be tough, especially if you’ve been a lifetime smoker. To help you break your nicotine addiction, Medicare will pay for eight in-person counseling sessions per year. But note that Medicare’s drug coverage will not pay for stop-smoking products sold over the counter at drugstores, like nicotine patches, lozenges, and gum.
4. Some Hearing Exams
Basic Medicare usually won’t pay for hearing aids or routine hearing tests. But it may cover a hearing exam if your doctor says it’s medically necessary. Hearing is related to balance. When a senior is having balance issues, a physician may want to check the ears to see if there’s an inner ear problem requiring medical treatment.
5. Hospice Care
Hospice care comprises a host of treatments at the end of a person’s life. Medicare will pay for a long list of hospice services, including nursing care, and grief and loss counseling for the patient and family. Hospice coverage applies when a Medicare recipient has been given six months or less to live and has agreed to forgo further attempts at a cure. Medicare-certified hospice care usually takes place where you already live — whether that be at home or in a nursing home. You can also receive hospice care in an inpatient facility. However, it’s important to note Medicare doesn’t cover your room and board, though it may pay for a short-term stay at a hospice facility if your hospice team determines you need that. If you’re dealing with any other health issues not related to your terminal illness, that should also still be covered by Medicare. But the government’s Medicare site points out that’s fairly unusual. Once you select hospice care, the hospice benefit typically covers everything you need.
6. Counseling for Alcohol Problems
Much like smoking, alcohol abuse can have seriously negative effects on the wellness of an older person. Medicare provides alcohol misuse screening and treatment free of charge. It covers one screening per year and up to four brief counseling sessions if the reviewing physician believes a patient needs help.
7. Disease Screenings
Medicare covers screenings for numerous diseases as part of its preventive services. Medicare will pay for testing to detect HIV and other STDs, diabetes, glaucoma, breast and cervical cancer, colon and prostate cancer, and heart disease. Patients with histories of smoking can get an annual lung cancer screening, and Medicare also covers annual screenings for depression and other behavioral health issues that are a concern for seniors.
8. Special Footwear for Diabetes
One of the least-known Medicare benefits is its allowance for specialized shoes for people with diabetes. The disease can cause poor or abnormal circulation in the feet, and a lack of proper treatment can result in the need for amputation. Another risk is diabetic neuropathy, which can damage nerve endings in the feet. Diabetic footwear helps regulate circulation and reduce the danger of neuropathy. Medicare will pay for one pair of custom-molded shoes and inserts and a pair of extra-depth shoes if they’re prescribed and provided by a podiatrist or other qualified health professional. Your insurance will also cover another two pairs of inserts for your custom-molded shoes and three pairs of inserts for extra-depth shoes each calendar year.
9. Wheelchairs and Scooters
Wheelchairs and mobility scooters are important tools to help those with debilitating conditions lead normal lives. Medicare will pick up the cost under certain circumstances. The wheelchair or scooter must be considered medically necessary. Your doctor would need to certify that you are unable to walk without difficulty. The physician would be required to write a prescription for the vehicle or wheelchair after giving you an exam.
10. A Walk-In Bathtub (Maybe)
A walk-in tub can help those with joint problems or other issues that make climbing into a traditional bathtub difficult or impossible. Medicare may help with the cost of a walk-in tub, even though the tubs are not on the list of “durable medical equipment” that Medicare will cover, including wheelchairs, oxygen equipment, and hospital beds. In order for you to obtain coverage, your doctor would have to attest that a walk-in tub is an absolute medical necessity. Medicare wouldn’t provide assistance upfront — after you buy the tub, you’d submit the bill for possible reimbursement. But there’s no guarantee that you’ll get your money back.
Get Help Making the Most of Your Medicare Benefits
These little-known Medicare benefits can add real value to your coverage — but they only help if you know about them. I’m Andy Orlikoff, an independent Medicare broker in Surprise, AZ. I help Arizona seniors understand their Medicare Supplement options and maximize their benefits. My help is free.
